Late edit: Wow, forgot about the rule change this year. Instead of bottom 2 get cut, top 3 move on. So we have 12 whittled to 3 this week, same next week, same week after, and then there's 9 left. That changes my calculation a bit.
Moving on: Ricky, Tatiana, Danny -- I think. Alexis was given good points but she went early and was unmemorable. Michael wasn't great but is super likable and a redneck, so flip a coin I guess. --
First performance night.
Randy is a fucking idiot. "Yo dawg, you gotta really be in it to win it tonight." Really?
Theme: Hits From The Billboard Hot 100 Since The Charts Began
Jackie: "Little Less Conversation" ... not bad looking, but omfg awful. Shrieking. Worst outfit ever, looks like a hot fudge sundae. Her voice is actually painful. Loud cheers, inexplicably. LOL Paula -- "It wasn't a perfect performance, but perfect sometimes is boring." Jackie's dad is wearing a beret for some reason. Her mom looks like Streganona.
Ricky: "A Song For You" ...I like this guy. I mean, the type of music is awful, stuff you hear in Macy's. Pretty good voice, all in all. Randy: "The star of season 8 right here." Simon: "No star quality." Debbie Downer.
Alexis: Some Aretha song ... She looks pretty dated. And albino. I guess she has a reasonable set of pipes. Not anything to write home about. Randy: "You done found the dirt, you done found the soul." Try deciphering that. Simon gushes. She kinda looks like a girl out of
Mad Men.
Brent: "Hicktown" (lol) ...This is like a techno country song. White Zombie meets Garth Brooks. This guy is cool, fills the generic flyover-state-vote-getter slot. Randy: "You're kinda like an old edge to country with a new country swagger." Paula: "I can definitely see you as a country star. Look what has happened to Bucky Covington." What the fuck. Is Bucky Covington even alive?
Stevie: Some Taylor Swift crap ...Kinda hot. A bit clownish. Her voice isn't good. If Taylor Swift was a post-pubescent male, she would sound like this girl. Randy: "That was not hot for me." Kara: "Who are you?" Simon: "Terrible."
Anoop: "Angel of Mine" ...Slumdog, Kumar, chicken tikka, Gandhi, IT support... OK. THERE ARE NO INDIAN MEN ON THE POP CHARTS. Dude, give it up. It is as if my Dell CS rep started serenading me. He looks like Aladdin. Please, just get out. Randy: "Interesting song choice." Translated: Omfg awful. Paula: "America has connected with you in a large way already." What? Anoop gives a floor speech defending his song choice to Simon. Simon seems to think "Angel of Mine" came out in 1987.
Casey: "Every Little Thing She Does is Magic" ...This girl is smoking. She'll ride it Haley Scarnato-style. Which is fortunate, because her voice is really weak. Randy: "Not good." Kara: "Everything about that was wrong." Simon: "You look good." Girl is about to cry. Simon: "Karaoke." She's a lock for awhile, she's really good-looking.
Michael: That popular Gavin DeGraw song ...He is doing a really bad little dance. I would describe it as a jig. Thoroughly unremarkable. Paula cites the fact that Bo Bice, Elliot Yamin, and Chris Richardson sang the song. Not sure what that means. Simon likes him.
Ann Marie: "A Natural Woman" ...So bad. Bad bad bad. Pretty decent looking. Not much more to say. Randy: "Subpar. I didn't understand who you were as an artist from that." Kara: "I look at you, I want to hear 'Love Song' by Sara Bareilles." Simon: "The crowd... easily pleased."
Stephen: "Rock With You" ...Mostly okay, until he started screaming. Randy: "Not the joint for you to be singing." What an idiot. This dude is cool. Simon: "Pointless.. the last ten second were okay." What the hell. Total alternate reality.
Tatiana: Some Whitney crap ...I'm guessing this will suck hard. This girl blows, and she's a Jesus nut. I can barely hear her. She's actually not bad. Decent rendition. Standing O. Randy: "You had some moments there." Kara: "Who are you?" STOP ASKING THIS YOU DUMB BITCH. Paula: "I don't know who you are today." Okay, seriously, it's the first fucking episode. Shut up. Simon: "You are a complete and utter drama queen."
Danny: Some Mariah crap ...Paula just stood up. I don't get why anyone thinks that people want to hear a guy sing Mariah Carey songs. I guess it's what you have to do to win Idol. It's like courting the evangelicals. This was awful. Never again. His wife just died though, so everyone is clapping and screaming. What the fuck. Oh my god. Randy: "Blazing hot." Kara: "You are the hero." Paula: "Stellar." Simon: "Your wife is rotting in the ground so I have to say something complimentary." No, really, he said "It was good."